
Notice the picture of Rafael Palmeiro there. It's not just any picture; it's the 1987 Topps baseball card. Why choose this picture? Well, it's the only year I collected baseball cards. That year, I obsessively collected Topps baseball cards. I collected the entire set by buying the 20 card packages with the crunchy piece of bubblegum inside. (Even though the gum was disgusting, I still chewed it everytime. It was a matter a principle. It was just the right thing to do.) Though I collected the entire set, that still wasn't enough for me that year. I bought the complete set, which to this day remains sealed in the long, green, rectangular box it came in. In 1987, I knew that such foresight and discipline would make me a millionaire in just a few short years.
Sometime during 2002, I came across this complete, still unopened 1987 set. (Over the fifteen years, I had actually forgotten about the treasure.) Upon finding the sealed green box, I went to the local card shop to see how many hundreds, even thousands, of dollars I might get. I expected the clerk to start salivating and make me a generous offer. After all, the set contained rookie cards for McGwire, Bonds, and Bo Jackson.
So, I casually walked up to the counter and told the clerk of my unopened complete set and asked if he had any interest.
He gave me a kinda annoyed and unapologetic "No."
Shocked, I asked what such a set might be worth.
He thought for a minute, and then, with a very pensive look on his face, said,
"If you put 'em in the spokes of your bicycle, it makes a pretty cool noise."
A part of me died that day. Needless to say, my cards were/are worth nothing. In fact, you can get a 1987 Topps set on ebay now for less than I paid in '87. Since then, I've been told the 1986 set is actually worth some pretty decent money. But, apparently everyone had my idea in 87.
Why did I think of this sad, sad story? Actually, I was looking for any picture of Palmeiro on google when suddenly I was attacked by nostalgia. As you might have heard, Raffy tested positive for steroids recently. Palmeiro has always been one of my favorite players; I love watching him bat. I think he has the sweetest, purest left handed swing I've ever seen. And, I was shocked when I heard he tested positive.
As I've mentioned before, I'm a pretty loyal listener to sports radio. I used to like it a lot more than I do now, but old habits die hard; if I'm in my car, and if I'm not listening the
Kidd Kraddick in the Morning,
I'm most likely listening to some blowhard bitch about what's wrong with sports. I used to really like listening to these guys, but as I've gotten older, I've realized that most of them are really pretty bad at making a point. I would call most of the hosts "shock jocks"--that is, talk show hosts that express extreme opinions just to be controversial, and, ostensibly, to garner an intrigued listening audience. Because these guys tend to be so extreme, they generally tend to be wrong on most points, and really annoying to boot.
But anyway, today they were bitching about Palmeiro, which was no big surprise. (You should have heard them after the Kenny Rogers tantrum. It was hillarious.) Again, I listened to half a dozen "it-wasnt-like-this-in-the-good-old-days" and "baseball is doomed" arguments (I have satelite radio, so I have four sports channels). I've come to expect this these diatribes.
But what really made me want to talk about Palmeiro here is that most thought that he ought not be allowed into the hall of fame. Essentially, the argument is that his 500 homeruns and 3000 hits are voided by probable steroid use. I completely disagree.
Now, I am not going to make an argument that seeks to justify steroid use or alleged lying to congress under oath (which Palmeiro might have done a few weeks ago). I'll even allow that Raffy's numbers might be inflated by various factors. My deal is this:
I don't really care if he used steroids. If it were my choice, I wish he wouldn't, but regardless, I still love watching Raffy swing the bat. Steroids are inconsequential to me.
Professional baseball players do things that I could never dream of doing. It's an amazing spectacle of skill and instinct everytime the take the field, whether juiced or not. I marvel, and they entertain me. That they might have been on steroids or otherwise banned substance doesn't diminish their achievement for me. I didn't miss "my shot" because some ol' boy chemically altered his body. Nor am I related to Roger Maris or Babe Ruth; I never even saw them play. What I have seen (Palmeiro, Bonds, Sosa, McGwire, Griffey), I've enjoyed from afar. I remember how great it felt in '98 watching McGwire achieve the unthinkable, hitting 62 homeruns, with Sosa giving him a run for his money up until the very end. It was great to watch, whether they were juiced or not.
Baseball is entertainment. I have no other stake in it. For the last fifteen years, steroids have been all but allowed. I'm quite sure that more people used them than we will ever know about. I think the playing field was quite level. (I feel similarly about the salary structure. I really don't care who spends what. I just like seeing great teams. Great teams are entertaining.)
So as for Raffy making the Hall of Fame? I think he absolutely should. He played in, perhaps, a juiced era of baseball, but, in it, he accomplished amazing feats that distinguishes himself from the rest, and he was one of the more likable players in the game.
I did find
one journalist who went against the grain on this issue. Jayson Stark argues that Rafael Palmeiro should unquestionably go into the hall. As a voter, he declares that his ballot will vote for Raffy the first and every time.
...it's not my job to police this sport. It's the sport's job to police itself. And for 15 years -- maybe 20 -- baseball's police station was a place where the cops just sat around, played cards, smoked cigars and let the inmates hit 900-foot home runs.Baseball's idea of policing itself in the '90s was to allow a whole generation of players to play -- without testing them, without punishing them, without preventing them from bulking up however they wanted.
So if they "cheated," it wasn't because I let them cheat. It was because baseball let them cheat.
...So all I know is that Rafael Palmeiro had a Hall of Fame career on those fields he was allowed to play on.